In response to Lily Ray’s blog posting on July 25, 2014 titled
Rant of the Day: Plastic Bag Ban found on her blog titled Texas Toast, I must
respectfully disagree with her opinion that the plastic bag ban in Austin is a
good thing. As a resident of Hutto/Round
Rock where there is not a plastic bag ban, I have found myself carrying my
groceries out of an Austin HEB in a donated cardboard box due to me not having
any reusable bags in my possession and forgetting about the Austin bag ban
until it is too late. Is it
inconvenient? Absolutely, but that is
not what I am going to base my argument on.
Life is full of inconveniences, and I can live with that.
Lily’s blog mentions how plastic bags clog up creeks and
cause millions of wildlife deaths. In my
opinion, the blame does not lie in the bag.
The blame lies with the person that threw it on the
ground…..littering. I don’t throw my
bags on the ground. I reuse them over and over again as lunch bags. When I have an overabundance of bags, I take
them to the store and recycle them. They
do not go in the landfill, and they do not go around an innocent duck’s neck.
We, meaning society, cannot do away with everything that
causes harm or is not handled responsibly.
Let’s take offshore oil drilling as an example. Wildlife, tourism, and the fishing industry
all suffered tremendously when the BP oil spill of 2010 dumped 4.9 million of
barrels into the ocean. Have we stopped
offshore drilling? No. I realize this comparison is on a much larger
scale, but my point is that when people act irresponsibility, you do not have
to do away with the item in question.
In summary, I disagree with the ban bag and believe that
education in the form of littering campaigns, organized cleanups, and the
addition of more recycling centers would be a better solution. Elimination is not the only means of keeping
the environment healthy.